Sarah Wilson makes it clear: she’s another false-equivalence advocate. I have to say, though, it’s only since the government told people they should be preparing for… that Rupert Read has been pushing pro-social prepping and then trying to tell everyone they are the only ones who came up with the idea, until he is challenged. By Solidarity Prepping on Bluesky. Now he’s telling us all they are the only people offering psychosocial resilience, and all I can see is the offering of a fake shaman new age grifter.

Wellbeing, recovery and spirituality: From grifters colonially helping themselves to indigenous people’s culture, misrepresenting it and selling it to you as part of your climate grief recovery. At the same time, they deny: Post 1.5°C, we lose the Goldilocks climate niche for growing food & more importantly, grain. They describe honesty like this as dystopian. Remember, these grifters will tell you stockpiling food isn’t helpful, and they will use false-equivalence arguments to show how unable they are to distinguish between their own ignorance and the skills required to plan for collapse.
Sarah Wilson noticeably has little to say about how we cope day to day with climate anxiety, though she admits she has suffered from generalised anxiety. Again, the climate majority is an anticlimax. Read tells people there is information about preparedness on the climate majority website, but there isn’t, because it’s a Think Tank, not an advice site. I find Wilson’s belief that “Collapse is not the end of the world; it’s the end of a system. A system that no longer serves us.” to be deeply flawed and ignores most of the impacts of climate change, especially the collapse of agriculture, though she also looks like the sort of person who eats next to nothing apart from her daily diet of dark chocolate (sugar-free, I presume).
Psychosocial Resilience
Psycho-social resilience for the climate emergency and collapse isn’t on the Climate Majority Website either. My influence for climate collapse acceptance was the late Michael Dowd, with whom I had many conversations before he died. Acceptance of collapse is central to psychosocial resilience.
In 2017/18, when working in a working-age adult psychiatric ward, I started a pilot project doing conservation and nature therapy with patients under section, detained in a number of wards. This award-winning project was inspiring at a time when research on how the human body responds to nature was surging. It developed new technology and theoretical psychological frameworks to show how deeply humans are connected to nature, and how nature can be a universal salve for anxiety, but it also needs us to do that personal work. The personal work being to go through the process of ecological collapse grief and the five non-linear stages of grief:
Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression, and Acceptance
Non-linear; you can cycle through them in no particular order, back and forth and ultimately acceptance is the liberation. I’m sure you have noticed Rupert Read saying we can perhaps avoid collapse: that’s the bargaining and denial stage
The problem with the belief that “Collapse is not the end of the world; it’s the end of a system. A system that no longer serves us” is that it’s both collapse denial and hopium. We are in overshoot, and unsurprisingly, it’s terrifying.
“If we all…”
The Neo-shamans want us to honour fear, and they will make money out of you teaching you all about honouring your fear. Collapse is an initiation into fear; we can start by facing the small things we fear. We can use mindfulness to observe fear and anguish. Stop honouring stuff.
Did you know gardening can cure anxiety? Dig Deep. “For people whose inner worlds feel chaotic, disconnected or exhausted, the garden can offer structure, connection and a chance to feel part of something alive.” Social and Therapeutic Horticulture: the emphasis is not on production but on recovery and engagement with nature. Can you believe I encouraged patients to hug trees, and they loved it. It helped them recover and find meaning in nature. Sometimes people need that permission. These offerings should never cost the people needing them. Notice how the terminology is different. The fake shaman talks about healing. Mental health practitioners talk about recovery because they understand that the patient goes through recovery, and recovery isn’t linear. Healing is much more final — “you are healed”, or my job is done, and it’s easier to blame or charge the client more for more healing. Language is important.
Meaningful activity and recovery. Neo-shamans have a habit of trying to tell you things which are neither possible nor true: “trauma is stored in the body”. Trauma is stored in the brain, and it can impact the body. Trauma is treated by tricking the brain into doing something differently. Meaningful activity is important; it’s important because people with PTSD need to know that any activity they are doing makes sense.
Nature, survival skills and interpersonal connection. Pro-social learning in nature benefits our mental health: Many people, especially men, find a deep connection to nature and each other by learning wilderness survival skills together in small, pro-social groups.
I’m still looking for the Climate Majority’s unique approach to psychosocial resilience, one that doesn’t rely on hoping things aren’t as bad as they are. I am going to be looking for some time.
Leave a Reply